To Tank or Not to Tank, Water Heating System - Which is right for your home?
Mike Segreto • December 21, 2022

To Tank or Not to Tank, Water Heating System - Which is right for your home?


In general, a water heater will last for 6 to 12 years with proper maintenance. This means you’ll have to replace your water heater from time to time. 


Today, there are a couple of different options for a new water heating system. You can use a traditional system that uses a tank, or a tankless system that uses a heat exchanger to heat the water as it flows through the system.


Which system is right for your home? Several factors can help you make that decision.


Energy Efficiency

In most cases, a tankless system uses less energy because it doesn’t have to heat an entire tank of water. 


If you still prefer traditional water heaters in Pelham, NY, you can improve the energy efficiency of your unit by wrapping it with an insulation blanket. In using a blanket, make sure the blanket is properly rated for your type of water heater, which will be electric or gas.


Newer tanks do come with better insulation installed. A plumbing contractor can help you compare energy efficiency ratings for traditional systems.


Upfront and Long-Term Costs of Water Heaters in Pelham, NY

When dealing with the upfront costs, the prices of both traditional and tankless water heaters are within similar ranges. For instance, you will find that gas systems are generally more expensive than electric systems in both types of water heaters.


Tankless systems can offer lower long-term costs. Since they use less energy, you’ll likely see a drop in your monthly utility bills. Additionally, tankless systems last twice as long as traditional tanks. A tankless system can last for up to 20 years.


Convenience and Accessibility

When choosing water heaters in Pelham, NY, you should consider your household’s needs. A tankless system heats water as needed, so there may be an issue with high demand. In a home where multiple people are using hot water at the same time, the availability of heated water may be somewhat limited.


Alternatively, a heated tank can supply hot water until the tank is empty. Once emptied, it may take up to an hour to refill the tank and heat the water. A larger tank will last longer.


Trust the Water Heater Pros

The professionals at MJ Plumbing Heating Cooling have proudly served the Pelham, NY, area since 1988. Whether you choose a traditional or tankless water heater, we’ll be happy to install it for you and will provide you with prompt, quality service. Contact us today!


Plumbing professionals performing a residential sewer inspection in New Rochelle, NY.
By Mike Segreto June 28, 2026
Learn how a sewer inspection in New Rochelle, NY can identify blockages, root intrusion, pipe damage, and other issues before costly repairs are needed.
Plumber performing a sewer camera inspection to identify underground pipe damage and blockages.
By Mike Segreto May 25, 2026
Discover how a sewer camera inspection in New Rochelle, NY can identify hidden sewer line issues early and help prevent costly repairs.
Mallard plumber inspecting a kitchen faucet and plumbing system affected by hard water.
By Mike Segreto May 25, 2026
Learn how hard water damages pipes, water heaters, and fixtures. Discover the benefits of hard water treatment in Warminster, PA.
Close-up of clogged shower head with mineral buildup in residential bathroom New Rochelle NY.
By Mike Segreto April 24, 2026
Discover common causes of low water pressure in New Rochelle, NY. Learn how clogged aerators, PRVs, and old pipes affect your plumbing system.
Modern high-efficiency boiler installed in home providing energy-efficient heating and comfort.
By Mike Segreto March 20, 2026
Upgrade to a high-efficiency boiler for lower energy bills, better comfort, and fewer repairs. Learn why it’s a smart investment for your home heating system.
MJ Plumbing technician repairing boiler system in a basement showing signs of age and wear.
By Mike Segreto December 24, 2025
Frequent boiler repairs, rising energy bills, or leaks? Learn the top signs it may be time for a new boiler installation in New Rochelle.
Show More